![]() |
|||
![]() |
|
||
Clonal Development for Willow Biomass - Biofuels Production
Objective: Establish experimental plantings of 39 willow and poplar clones to determine clonal and environmental effects on growth, understand foliar development patterns, biomass partitioning, nutrient use efficiency, and understand pest utilization of clones. Approach/Background: The State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry (SUNY-ESF) is expanding its willow genetic improvement program to meet future needs for genetically improved willow clones. Basic physiological information on clones currently being propagated and tested on a large scale, and new clones being propagated in preparation for testing, is necessary to assist in clonal selection and the overall genetic improvement effort. Large genotype-by-environment interaction is a problem facing willow breeders and the physiological basis of these interactions is poorly understood. Status/Accomplishments: 1997-1999: A genetic selection trial was established in May 1997 after appropriate site preparation, containing 32 willow and 7 hybrid poplar clones at 0.6 m by 0.9 m spacing at Tully, NY. The plants were coppiced (cutback) in winter 1997-98. The experimental design was a randomized complete block with four replications. A sister study was planted during June 1997 in Rhinelander, WI in cooperation with the USDA Forest Service. Two smaller trials using a subset of 10 willow clones were planted in WI in May 1999. An additional trial was planted in East Lansing, MI in May 1999 with 14 willow and two hybrid poplar clones. As all studies mature, efforts will be made to compare results. In the NY trial, various clone and site variables are being measured such as frost damage, insect and disease incidence, tree growth and stem dimensions and date of bud break and leaf senescence. Physiological measurements being carried out on five select clones include foliar development patterns, light interception and biomass partitioning patterns. In addition, standard meteorological variables were measured. 1998-1999: In addition to the ongoing measurements detailed above, soil texture and soil chemistry will be characterized at the end of this growing season. At the end of first year after coppice, the mean height of the willows (1.44m ± 0.32) and poplar (1.53m ± 0.20) was similar. Mean stem diameter of the willow clones was less than that of the hybrid poplar clones. The number of stems per stool, however, was greater for willows (10.4 + 3.3) than poplar (5.2 + 1.7). Oven dry stool biomass after one growing season ranged from 199.0g to 447.63g. Stool biomass was similar between the willows (268.5g + 103.5) and poplars (233.3g + 77.1). Publications and Presentations:
Summary Date: June 1999 |
|||
Development of Pest-Resistant Cottonwood Clones for Biomass Energy Production in the North Central Region
Objective: Develop new cottonwood clones for commercial energy plantation uses in the region and to support research on the inheritance of pest resistance including the cottonwood leaf beetle, Septoria stem canker, Melampsora leaf rust and expression of hybrid vigor in biomass yields. We are specifically targeting the selection of clones that will produce 9 to 10 dry tons/ac/yr of biomass. Raising the biological production capabilities of plantations through fast establishment and less risk of loss to pests is one of the targeted means for producing biomass at a cost of $2.00/million Btu. Developing genetic resistance to pest problems means higher biomass yield and less pesticide use, and selecting genotypes that perform on a variety of sites means biomass plantations can make a better contribution to landscape ecology and rural economies. Approach/Background: Selected parents are being mated in a directed pedigree. Replicated family field trials are grown for 3 yrs before the best individuals are selected, cloned, and further tested. Evaluations for leaf diseases are done in summer; growth rate, sylleptic branching, and other morphological traits are evaluated in fall each year. Clones that pass all of these tests are then provided to a separate U.S. Forest Service/ORNL project for longer-term evaluation in replicated clonal field plots planted in IA, MI, MN, and WI. Clones that still look promising would are released for commercial testing in yield plots. Supporting research is being done to determine the yield impacts of the cottonwood leaf beetle using Bt-treated and control plots. The geographic population structure of the leaf rust is being investigated using markers for 3 micro-satellite loci in M. medusae. The interactions of host leaf-surface chemistry and insect pheremones in the cottonwood leaf beetle's ability to find and colonize poplar plantings are being studied to find biological controls for this problem. Status/Accomplishments: In 1998-9, we completed 88 crosses and produced over 10,000 seedlings. Twenty new clones have been prepared for the next regional test. Thirty-one new clones are ready for release for full-scale testing in plantations. These clones exceed "Eugenei' stem volume production by as much as 82% and should be more resistant to or tolerant of pathogens. A single, dominant gene for Melampsora rust resistance has been identified and is being further evaluated. We found Cryptosphaeria populina attacking and killing DN hybrids in 2 Iowa plantings, so we have initiated an inoculation trial to determine the taxonomic host range for this pathogen, previously found to cause significant disease only on aspen. We are investigating a potential relationship between an Agrilus borer, the taxonomic background of a clone, and the Cryptosphaeria disease. During the first two seasons, we have shown that CLB feeding can reduce stem volumes by as much as 59%. Publications and Presentations:
Summary Date: September 1999 |
|||
Limitations on Short Rotation Woody Crop Growth in the Southeast United States
Objective: Evaluate whole-plant carbon budgets for individual clones or species to determine the relative limitations placed on above-ground production by respiratory processes in stems, branches and roots and test the impacts of fertigation on tissue-specific physiological parameters. Approach/Background: Populus sp. have shown tremendous potential for woody biomass production in northern latitudes, but have failed to maintain this level of performance in the southeastern United States. Conversely, species such as Platanus occidentalis and Liquidambar styraciflua generally appear over the long run to be better suited for high productivity in southeastern locations. Increased temperatures represent a predominant climate feature differentiating northern and southern locations, and suggest a couple of reasons for degraded performance of Populus productivity in the S.E. United States. Increased temperatures will lead to greater respiratory losses from stem, branches and root tissues without proportionate increases in the photosynthetic production from leaves and high temperatures may also accelerate transpiration resulting in a greater potential for the development of drought limitations in the absence of sufficient rainfall inputs. We hypothesize that inherently different photosynthesis/respiration rates among genotypes of a single species or between species may help to explain observed rates of biomass production in the southeast where high temperature are likely to contribute to a reduction in net carbon gain at the whole plant level Status/Accomplishments: FY98. Season long climatic, edaphic and physiological measurements were made and used to construct a process-based growth model for all three species. Individual-tree biomass equations were developed to predict component growth and yields for each species. Yield equations do not vary significantly by treatment or by clone or by age, though the regression models do vary by species and component per species. Irrigation and fertilizer amendments do not appear to be able to overcome limitations in growth rate occurring in mid-rotation, though absolute growth is higher in irrigated and fertilized treatments. FY99. Season long climatic, edaphic and physiological measurements were made and used to verify the process-based growth model for all three species. Individual-tree biomass equations for each biomass component growth and yields for each species were adjusted based on additional data. It appears that leaf area index (LAI) is closely linked to water consumption and growth, though at this point it is not clear which of the three processes is controlling the relationship. LAI in sycamore appears to respond favorably to increased water availability even after crown closure has occurred. Fertilization at the tested levels does not seem to have an effect on LAI or on leaf N levels. Publications and Presentations: Annual oral presentations were made to corporate partners that included protected CRADA information, as well as general performance summaries by species and treatment. No referred publications have been submitted for corporate approval for public release at this time. Summary Date: September 1999 |
|||
Physiology of Poplar Disease Resistance
Objective: Hybrid poplars developed by the WSU-UW program are one of the fastest growing temperate trees in the world. Introducing WSU-UW hybrid poplars into other regions of the US would allow for significant production of biomass for energy. To do this, it will be necessary to control diseases that limit growth. This project determines various physiological and morphological traits of disease resistance in hybrid poplar. The two most important diseases that limit poplar productivity in the U.S. are Melampsora leaf rust and Septoria stem canker. Selection and breeding for resistant planting stock is the only economically viable means of eliminating or minimizing the impacts of these two diseases. Approach/Background: Task 2: Mechanisms of Disease Resistance Subtask 2: Septoria canker; understand host/site factors controlling infection. Objective: To understand how soil and nutrition may control resistance to Septoria infection. A study was conducted in May 1999 to test if soil pH affects bark pH, which, in turn, inhibits stem infection by Septoria populicola. Cuttings of five TD clones were rooted under mist and transplanted into pots containing soil. One third of the pots were amended with lime to raise soil pH to 8, one third were treated with phosphoric acid to lower soil pH to 4 and the remaining pots were controls with a soil pH of 6. After one month, the petioles were inoculated with spores of Septoria populicola. Presence of lesions after two months was taken as a successful infection. Task 3: Growth and Physiological Impacts of Disease. Subtask 1: Changes in carbon, water and nutrient allocation during symptom development in known susceptible and resistant clones. Objectives: To understand physiological changes that occur during the infection process and symptom manifestation, and to begin to identify quantifiable traits related to host physiology. Greenhouse research was conducted using leaf rust-host differentials. A study comparing the response of one clone to a virulent and an avirulent pathotype was started. Status/Accomplishments: Task 2: Mechanisms of Disease Resistance Subtask 2: The treatments were significant at a P = 0.08 level, suggesting that soil pH affecting bark pH may not be the mechanism of resistance, but may be correlated to resistance. This study used Septoria populicola which normally doesn't form stem lesions like its midwest relative, S. musiva. Task 3: Growth and Physiological Impacts of Disease. Subtask 1: One greenhouse study has been completed, but the infection intensity was very low. Viability of this pathotype is now being assessed. Another, more virulent pathotype may need to be used for future studies. Publications and Presentations:
Summary Date: December 1999 |
|||
Poplar Molecular Genetics Cooperative
Objective: The goals of the PMGC are to: 1) increase understanding of the molecular genetic mechanisms causing variation in productivity and quality traits in hybrid poplar; and, 2) use research results to accelerate progress in poplar breeding for biomass yield. Approach/Background: The key to sustained genetic improvement in Populus is a detailed understanding of traits such as biomass yield, wood chemistry, and disease resistance. This will accelerate progress in breeding by providing improved methods to identify superior poplar clones for immediate commercial use, parents for the next generation of hybrids, and isolated genes for biotechnological manipulation. The first element in a genetics program is the production of informative pedigrees. The PMGC is breeding five species of Populus with proven value for biomass plantations: P. trichocarpa, P. deltoides, P. nigra, P. maximowiczii, P. balsamifera. Broad geographic ranges were covered to assure production of new clones adapted to most of North America. Breeding efforts were concentrated on production of F1 interspecific hybrids since they consistently outperform pure species. The second element of the PMGC research program is the development of genomics tools, such as genetic markers and large-insert DNA libraries, suitable for the isolation of individual genes affecting biomass yield and quality. Status/Accomplishments: The PMGC has attracted member organizations from three continents, four countries, fourteen companies, four government agencies, and three universities. The annual PMGC budget leverages DOE funding more than 10-fold. The PMGC has produced more than 15,000 new hybrid poplar clones for testing and deployment by member organizations; in many cases these represent the first new germplasm tested in a decade. Field trials are in place from Chile to Canada, and from Washington to Florida. Many of these clones appear to be highly promising in terms of biomass yield. The PMGC has developed the first and most extensive collection of microsatellite markers for Populus. These markers are now in use by researchers around the world for comparing genetic maps among poplar pedigrees, determining clonal identity for quality control, paternity testing, and estimation of gene flow from plantation forests into native stands. A bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) genomic library, suitable both for cloning genes and for the eventual construction of a physical map of the Populus genome, has been constructed. Publications and Presentations:
Summary Date: September 1999 |
|||
Populus Crop Development in the Southeast United States
Objective: Collect and develop improved genetic varieties (clones) of eastern cottonwood (Populus deltoides Bartr.) for use in energy and fiber crops throughout the southeastern United States. Identify sources (provenances) and clones best suited to various site types in different parts of the region. Determine DNA markers for use in source and clone identification. Approach/Background: Subdivide the Southeast into six sub-regions: (1) Southeast Atlantic (SA) from NC to GA, (2) East Gulf (EG) for AL, west FL, and east MS, (3) East Central (EC) for TN and west KY, (4) Lower MS River Valley (LM) for west MS and east LA, (5) West Gulf (WG) for west LA and east TX, and (6) West Central (WC) for west AR and east OK. Collect cuttings and establish breeding orchards and clone nurseries for tested clones from LM, WG, and WC. Collect seeds and leaves from natural stands in SA, EG, and EC. Extract DNA from leaves and find RAPD markers that can be used for clone and seed-source identities. Make controlled crosses among selected trees from LM, WG, and WC. Produce rooted, containerized cuttings from seedlings of controlled crosses and of seeds collected from natural stands. Plant the rooted cuttings in field trials at four sites (s.e. MO, s.w. AL, north FL, and n.e. NC) to screen for superior three-year growth and leaf-disease resistance. Status/Accomplishments: FY 1995-97: Established 214 tested clones from LM, WG, and WC in breeding orchards and clone nurseries. Located 72 natural stands in SA, EG, and EC. Attempts to make controlled crosses on limb cuttings were mostly unsuccessful, so this will be delayed until trees flower in the orchards. FY 1998: Collected seeds and leaves from 65 of the natural stands. Extracted DNA from 150 of 410 leaf samples. Grew seedlings from 188 trees in the natural stands and from 7 successful controlled crosses. FY 1999: Completed DNA extractions from leaves of 264 trees, and determined that sub-regions can be identified from RAPD markers. Produced 13,830 rooted cuttings from 1,402 seedling clones (for four field tests), and planted two sites (s.e. MO and north FL) that have drip irrigation. The other two tests will be planted in FY 2000. Publications and Presentations:
Summary Date: September 1999 |
|||
Regional Testing of Populus Clones
Objective: Our objective is to expand and accelerate poplar breeding and selection in the North Central United States by implementing a regional testing program for Minnesota, Iowa, Wisconsin and Michigan. This work is significant because there have been no regional cooperative tests of newly developed Populus clones in our region in the last 30 years. Approach/Background: This project provides estimates of genetic and environmental effects on the growth of new hybrid Populus clones by evaluating (1) the magnitude of clonal variation at each location relative to current commercial standards, (2) the stability of clonal performance across locations, and (3) how environmental conditions and the distribution of diseases affects stability. Common garden experiments are conducted where all clones to be tested are planted at each of four locations in Minnesota (MN), Iowa (IA), Wisconsin, and Michigan. Testing focuses on Eastern cottonwood (Populus deltoides) which has potential as a biofuels crop and is a native species in the North Central region. We also test inter-specific cottonwood hybrids and hybrid aspen We measure tree height, tree diameter, and the incidence of diseases. We then estimate variances attributable to locations, blocks within locations, clones, and the clone x location interaction. Variance and covariance components are used to estimate heritabilities on both an individual location basis and over all locations, clone x location interactions (an indication of stability) and genetic correlations among various plant traits. Status/Accomplishments: Two sets of tests were established thus far, one each in 1995 and 1997. Clones were obtained from Iowa State University and the University of Minnesota for inclusion in the 1995 planting based on age two year growth and resistance to leaf diseases. Fourth year height, diameter and above-ground biomass have been analyzed from the 1995 field tests. The main effects due to clone across the region for all measurements was small relative to the clone x location interaction. Clone x location interactions were especially characteristic of the MN and IA locations where combined analyses showed no significant main effect of clone. Inspection of clone means, correlation analyses and application of principal component analysis to the multi-location data set demonstrated that clones bred and selected in Iowa performed well at the IA test site while clones bred and selected in MN performed well at the MN test site. Opportunities to transfer clones between breeding programs in MN and IA appear limited. Clone effects and, thus, heritability remain strong at individual locations. Some experimental clones have demonstrated growth rates that are significantly greater then the commercial controls. Publications and Presentations:
Summary Date: September 1999 |
|||
Septoria Pathosystem Studies for Populus
Objective: The goal of this project is to minimize the damage to poplar biomass plantations caused by pathogens (eg., the fungi Septoria and Melampsora spp.). The objectives are to identify and develop poplar clones that have disease resistance or tolerance to other damaging agents (e.g. insects, drought). Approach/Background: This will be accomplished by (1) validating and characterizing disease resistance expressed by tissue culture-derived clones planted in Minnesota and Wisconsin, (2) assessing the level of genetic and pathogenic variation in Septoria spp., and (3) monitoring the impacts of disease in various clonal trials in order to identify resistant families and individual clones. Two species of Septoria affect native and introduced poplars in North America. S. musiva causes cankers of hybrid poplars in the north central and northeastern United States as well as in Ontario, Canada but is not present in the Pacific Northwest where many susceptible poplars are native or planted. S. populicola is present throughout North America, but does not cause cankers. The distribution and genetic variation of these pathogens need to known to effectively develop screening systems that can reliably be used test poplars for disease resistance. Tissue culture was used to regenerate plants (somaclones) from two poplar clones that expressed greater disease resistance than the original donor clones in laboratory and greenhouse studies. The distribution, molecular, and pathogenic variation among a large collection of Septoria spp. isolates are being examined using molecular markers and by challenging a selected set of poplar clones with the pathogens. Status/Accomplishments: A high degree of molecular genetic variation, but no isolate-clone specificity or geographical clustering was evident among isolates of S. musiva. However, S. musiva and S. populicola have different geographical and host ranges. The two species are difficult to identify by spore or cultural characteristics. Although S. populicola does not cause cankers in nature, it does have the ability to cause stem cankers in artificial inoculations of hybrid poplars in the greenhouse. S. musiva, however, is more aggressive. Several somaclones have outperformed their source clones in growth and have exhibited greater resistance or tolerance to stem cankers caused by S. musiva in replicated field tests in WI and MN. Selected somaclones will be propagated in stool beds and used for additional field and greenhouse tests. Clonal trials have been evaluated for resistance to the major diseases in the north central region. Pathogen populations and disease severity are being monitored in order detect any evidence for new pathogen species or the development of new races. Publications and Presentations:
Summary Date: September 1999 |
|||
Short Rotation Woody Crops Cooperative Research Program
Objective: The Short Rotation Woody Crops Cooperative Research (SRWC) Program was established to collect fundamental crop and soil data at the Department of Energy's Savanna River Site in cooperation with USDA-Forest Service, Savanna River Institute. Priority issues being investigated include understanding mechanisms involved in forest productivity, monitoring local environmental impacts of short-rotation forests, and studying insects and disease susceptibility. These core studies will supplemented with external funds brought to the SRWC Cooperative by industrial researchers and university collaborators. Approach/Background: A field experiment is being conducted that will study the response of cottonwood, sweetgum,, and sycamore to nutrient and water manipulations. The irrigation factor will include two levels, irrigated and non-irrigated. Eight fertilization treatment levels will be applied in combination with irrigation treatments. Site preparation will include shearing of any existing tree cover and raking. Piling and burning of debris will be in areas designated as roadways or plot borders. A deep root rake will be used to remove smaller stumps; larger stumps will be pulled. The land will be disked in at least two directions and harrow raked until acceptably level. Monitoring of stand responses to the various fertilization and irrigation treatments will be organized according to one of several objectives. These include quantification of growth, nutrient pools, nutrient fluxes, water relations and nutrient cycling, and other investigator initiated research issues relevant to SRWC. Status/Accomplishments: The SRWC Program initiated work on Experiment A, "Fundamental Controls of Growth and Productivity" during FY99. A suitable site was identified on the Savannah River Site consisting of 100 acres of level ground with a well-drained deep soil. The site was cleared of existing pine forest through a timber sale (April, 1999) and the ground was prepared by raking large-diameter surface debris (August, 1999) and then tilling and incorporating remaining debris including stumps to a depth of 12 inches using a 500 hp reclaimer/stabilizer (October, 1999). The ground was then disked (November, 1999) and lime applied (January, 2000). Initial soil samples were collected prior to timber harvest (March, 1999) for evaluating chemical and physical properties. Soil samples were also collected following removal of surface debris in cooperation Oak Ridge National Laboratory's Center for Carbon Sequestration (September, 1999). Experimental start date is set for the first of April, 2000 following completion of the irrigation system and tree planting. Fertilizer and irrigation treatments will be applied through October. Seedling survival, above- and below-ground growth and environmental parameters will be monitored throughout the growing season. Soil moisture samples will be collected monthly from lysimeters. Year-end harvest will be used to evaluate carbon and nutrient mass balance of the plantation during the critical establishment year. Publications and Presentations: None Summary Date: March 2000 |
|||
Testing of Willow Clones for Biomass Production in Wisconsin
Objective: The following objectives are important to assessing the potential of willows for biomass production in Wisconsin:
Approach/Background: Our goal is to assess the potential of willow clones for a bioenergy crop in the Lake States by assessing their productivity, conducting studies of basic physiology and morphology, and collecting material and information for selection and breeding. To accomplish this assessment, we have established replicated field trials of willow clones in Wisconsin and New York to facilitate the improved understanding of willow clones and the development of new clones for breeding. Our research contributes to the development of willow clonal stock available for planting bioenergy crops on a wide variety of sites in North America. The development of a strong and ongoing clonal improvement program through natural selections, biological characterizations, and tree breeding is of critical importance to the success and profitability of willow biomass crops. Status/Accomplishments: Our initial willow coppice study was established at the Harshaw Experimental Farm near Rhinelander, WI in 1997 with the same common 32 willow and 7 hybrid poplar clones used in a replicated test at Tully, NY. Measurements of mortality, height, diameter, leaf area, leaf nitrogen, and incidence of pests were taken throughout the 1997 season. In the winter of 1997/1998 after 1 year, the plantation was coppiced and allowed to resprout. In 1998 and 1999, the same measurements were taken as in 1997, as well as number of coppice sprouts. Height growth in 1998 after coppicing ranged from 31 to 129 cm and was hampered by problems with weed control and drought. Clones of Salix purpera and udensis performed best. Few insects and disease problems were observed. A herbicide screening study was established in 1998 with 5 willow clones and 7 herbicides. Under drought, the herbicide "Goal" gave "best" results and there was a significant clone x herbicide interaction. In 1999, moisture conditions at Harshaw improved and total height ranged from 1 to 26 m. A second herbicide study established in 1999 showed that height growth under a "better" moisture regime improved with the herbicide "Milestone". Mortality averaged 10% and a significant clone x herbicide interaction was again present. Collections of native Lake States and Canadian willows were also made and archived at Rhinelander, WI. Publications and Presentations:
Summary date: September 1999 |
|||
Tree Genetic Engineering Research Cooperative
Objective: To conduct research and transfer technology on the use of genetically engineered trees in short-rotation culture. The primary aim of TGERC research is to understand and mitigate environmental risks of transgenic plantations. Emphasis is placed on the study of means to genetically engineer floral sterility to prevent "genetic pollution," and analysis of the ecological consequences of transgene spread. Other projects include: improving transformation efficiency and testing the field performance of herbicide-, disease-, and insect-resistant transgenic trees. Using genetic engineering to supplement breeding of short-rotation trees can benefit biomass producers by: 1) enhancing tree growth, 2) facilitating use of marginal land, 3) improving feedstock quality, 4) decreasing management costs, and 5) reducing environmental impacts. Approach/Background: Interspecific hybridization has led to the development of very fast-growing lines of hybrid poplar. Some of these hybrid lines are now being grown in large commercial plantations throughout the U.S. and Canada. Poplars are primarily grown for pulp and biomass, but are also valuable for removal of agrochemicals from ground-water, bioremediation of polluted sites, and for stream bank stabilization and restoration. Genetic engineering will improve poplar's utility for short-rotation intensive culture. Although hybrid poplars have tremendous growth potential, they are very susceptible to insect herbivory, vegetative competition, and a variety of pathogens. Genes are that can ameliorate these shortcomings. Poplar is an ideal model system for woody plant genetic manipulation because it is easy to transform and vegetatively propagate, and has a small genome to facilitate gene isolation. Several poplar clones are readily transformed with Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Techniques developed in our laboratory have greatly improved the efficacy with which previously recalcitrant, but commercially important, clones can now be transformed and regenerated. Status/Accomplishments
Publications and Presentations
Summary Date: September 1999 |
|||
Plant Modification for Fuel Feedstock Enhancement
Objective: Evaluate the opportunities and limitations for using biotechnology to modify woody crop characteristics for use in bioenergy applications. Provide recommendations on research needs and most appropriate pathways for modifying woody crop characteristics. Approach/Background: The evaluation was conducted through an extensive survey of the literature on activities relevant to modifying crop characteristics using either classical genetics, genetic marker technology and genetic transformation. The information was collected and summarized in a report to DOE. Experts from USDA, academia, and industry were brought together in a workshop to evaluate the report and discuss research needs and pathways. Status/Accomplishments: The draft report was completed. The workshop was held during December 1999. The report is being finalized for submission to DOE. A summary of the material will be presented at the Biotechnology Conference to be held in Gatlinburg in May 2000. Publications and Presentations: None Summary Date: December 1999 |
|||
![]() |
![]() Last updated: Wednesday, 30-Aug-2000 08:03:45 EDT |