G2 Real Time Expert System, GDA and Neur-on-line

Prepared by:
Gensym Corporation

Prepared for:
Public purchase

Application:
Financial analysis:
Environmental impact analysis: ---
Waste management/P2:
Environmental cost listing/database: ---
Cost estimation: ---
Alternative product/process comparison: ---

Tools for real-time monitoring and analysis of processes. The greater efficiency afforded as a result of real-time monitoring will result in lower costs, although the systems are not designed to include any cost information. However, cost information could be incorporated into the systems (especially in the off-line applications). The systems have numerous environmental applications, including real-time process and environmental monitoring, identification and diagnosis of problems, and solutions. For example, G2 and GDA have been used for continuous emission monitoring for NOx from utility boilers, real-time monitoring of process and pollution control equipment, tracking waste content and burning, and modeling combustion processes to predict and reduce emission levels and optimize processes. In design applications, the systems may be used to design systems for the lowest life-cycle costs. The Batch Design Kit is an example of such an application.

Elements of control:
Cost control ---
Resource control ---
Estimating control ---
Schedule control ---
Scope control ---
Risk control

Development date and updates:
Gensym Corp. was founded in 1986. G2 Version 4.0 was released in July,1995. This is usually updated once a year. GDA version 2.0 was released in February, 1995. Neur-on-line version 1.0 was released in February, 1994. These two products are less frequently updated (in comparison to G2).

Public availability:
Available

Purpose and current use:
Gensym markets its products to companies with automated processes, government agencies responsible for environmental monitoring and remediation, agencies responsible for traffic control, etc. They have sold their products in over 30 industry sectors in over 30 different countries. The industries include process industries, discrete manufacturing, telecommunications, environmental, power, and aerospace. They have sold over 3,000 product licenses.

Cost information:
The range of prices for the products are $6,000 to $37,000. The prices vary with the options chosen and also differ between the on-line and off-line versions.

System requirements:
G2 Diagnostic Assistant (GDA): Offered on UNIX workstations from DEC, IBM,HP, and SUN, as well as DEC VAX systems. This requires:

Another system, Neur-On-Line, is additionally offered in Alpha AXP systems. The system requirements are the same as for GDA. 48 MB of memory is required for use with GDA.

Software summary

Size and complexity of projects:
The G2 systems seem more suitable for large, complex operations.

Other compatible systems offered:
Gensym brings out three different packages called G2 Real-Time Expert System, G2 Diagnostic Assistant, and Neur-On-Line.

Nonquantifiable information:
Information on any note-writing capability is not available.

Real-time expert systems are on-line knowledge-based systems that combine analytical process models with conventional process control and heuristics to judge and interpret sensory data, while reasoning about the past, present, and future to assess on-going developments and plan appropriate actions. G2real-time systems can be applied to address the following environmental areas:

Real-time expert systems have been used proactively to minimize leaks, emissions, and waste, as well as to improve product quality, production yield, and energy consumption. They can assist in monitoring for regulatory compliance and identification and diagnosis of unexpected process changes. A real-time system can assist in waste minimization by using ingredient information for a compound to suggest production alternatives and methods to minimize wastes and production costs. It can also do mass-balance calculations.

The G2 Real Time Expert System is used to monitor complex industrial processes and to assist in problem identification. It combines rule and model-based expert system reasoning, real-time execution, user interface graphics, and monitoring system and database interface capabilities.

The G2 diagnostic assistant (GDA) can be used along with G2 and is a graphical, object-oriented decision-making tool. GDA contains predefined graphical blocks that represent information fed into the system through user- or computer-generated input. This information is used to interpret and diagnose real-time data received from controllers and sensors. GDA can be used for problem diagnosis and decision support. Users can also create their own applications within G2. Besides identifying problems after they have occurred, problems can also be predicted using statistical techniques. It can be used for prototyping, modeling, and simulation.

Neur-on-line is designed as a visual, object-oriented tool for building neural networks to monitor complex processes that are difficult to monitor or control with conventional modeling tools or rule-based systems. Neur-on-line has to be integrated with G2 (also GDA), which will perform tasks such as filtering input data and taking actions on the resulting outputs from the neuralnet.

There are on-line and off-line versions of the systems. A tool kit for modeling applications included in the packages allows users to modify the systems as required.

The Emission Reduction Research Center (ERRC), Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), and Gensym are working on designing a Batch Design Kit using the G2 Real Time Expert System. This project was funded by a consortium of nine leading pharmaceutical and chemical companies, along with the US Army, New Jersey Commission on Science Technology, and the USEPA. The goal was to create a software toolkit for use in pharmaceutical and specialty chemical plants to reduce their environmental impacts (enable 'Zero Avoidable Pollution') by optimizing batch process design to minimize pollution. The Kit functions in a Computer Aided Design (CAD) environment for the design of batch processes with ecological constraints. Fed a list of ingredients for a given compound, the program will advise users of different production alternatives and help pinpoint methods that minimize wastes and production costs by selecting the most appropriate reactions; solvents, catalysts, diluents, etc.; reactors; separation and purification processes; and treatment units. General features of the Batch Design Kit include the following:

Idealized designs can be analyzed by enforcing environmental constraints, and more practical designs can be evolved by the guided relaxation of the constraints. Operating and capital costs can be allocated through integration with external databases. It is estimated that the kit would help companies save millions of dollars in non-compliance fines, waste product, and raw materials.

Life-cycle stages covered

Raw material acquisition ---
Manufacturing stage ---
Use/reuse/maintenance ---
Recycle/waste management ---

Real-time systems can be used to address any part of the life cycle. Thusin real-time applications, it will typically cover stages within one facility that can be monitored. All life-cycle stages will not be addressed in one application. However, in off-line applications, the modeling capability could be used to include information on all life-cycle stages. For example, expert systems could be used in designing applications to help in selecting materials with optimal life cycles, while determining things like reusability of parts, ease of disassembly, best use of materials, etc. However, the system is not preset or designed for this purpose.

Type of costs considered

Conventional ---
Potentially hidden ---
Contingent ---
External ---

The system is not designed to include cost information, but users could possibly adapt the system to include some variable costs through relationship models. However, users would need to develop estimation methods, such as costs related to material use (and other real-time data),= or external costs related to emissions on their own. The systems can be used to control some cost drivers by maximizing efficiencies. For example, predicting future problems such as leaks or emissions could reduce contingent and external costs (without actually estimating or recording them). Real-time data will allow quicker identification and solution of problems and possibly less damage. In off-line versions, cost information could be incorporated in system models. Since the systems can be modified according to user requirements, any cost information, if available, could be incorporated. However, the system is not designed for estimation or resource control and therefore cannot assist in cost estimation.

Method of cost estimation

The system is not designed for cost estimation.

Generation of financial indicators

Net present value (NPV) ---
Payback period ---
Internal rate of return (IRR) ---
Benefits cost ratio ---
Other ---

Ability to include environmental costs

User friendliness and flexibility

Gensym's Telewindows application provides a multiuser client/server environment that allows multiple users to share G2 applications. The bridge products enable plant-wide integration through standard interfaces to popular database and control systems (PLC, DCS). User-defined blocks can be created in GDA. Users can build and maintain applications without needing to do conventional programming. G2 can import bitmapped images and create trend charts for displaying real-time data. G2's internal clock works at subsecond levels for scheduling G2 events and keeping data histories at subsecond time intervals. All systems have graphical user interfaces with the option to use MS Windows or MOTIF style interfaces. The new tool kit for modeling allows users to develop and modify the system application as required.

User support

Gensym provides consulting services to its customers, including project prototyping, application engineering, project management, and customized training. Systems integration services include system architecture and data integration services. No demonstration disks are available. However, remote and on-site demos can be organized.

Limitations

These systems are primarily designed to collect and process real-time data from automatic processes; therefore, they are unsuitable for small, nonautomated operations. The software is not designed as a cost-estimating system or to include cost data. It is meant primarily to be used to handle technical aspects of project planning and monitoring but not other non technical (resource control, administration, management) elements.

Basis for evaluation:
Based on telephone communication with Gensym representative and information package received in March 1995. Additional information obtained from Rich(1995).

Contact information:
Commercially available

Gensym Corporation
125 Cambridge Park Drive
Cambridge, MA 02140

Joanne Prairie/Betsy Gartner/Steve Fraleigh
617-547-2500
617-547-1962 (FAX)


Return to the top of this document.

Return to the Chapter 4 Index

Return to the Table of Contents