OXYGEN COMPONENT ULTRASONIC CLEANING SYSTEM

Revision Date: 12/03
Process Code: Navy and Marine Corps: IND-001-99; Air Force: CL04; Army: CLD, PNT, VHM
Usage List: Navy: Medium; Marine Corps: Medium; Army: Medium; Air Force: Medium
Alternative For: Use of Freon (CFC-113) cleaning of oxygen system components
Compliance Impact: Low
Applicable EPCRA Targeted Constituents and CAS Numbers: CFC-113 Freon (CAS 76-13-1), vapor decreasing and cleaning solvents


Overview: The Oxygen Component Ultrasonic Cleaning System (OCUCS) is a type of equipment that combines the use of ultrasonic cleaning technology with a non-hazardous, environmentally preferred cleaning fluid. This equipment provides a pollution prevention opportunity by replacing systems that use CFC-113 or Freon as the cleaning medium.

The OCUCS uses Navy Oxygen Cleaner (NOC) fluid, which is an aqueous, inorganic alkaline solution manufactured for the U.S. Navy under MIL-DTL-24800. The NOC Aqueous Oxygen Cleaning Process is detailed in MIL-ST-1330D. The environmental advantage of this material is that it is a non-foaming, non-flammable material and contains no environmentally regulated materials, no ozone depleting potential, no greenhouse warming potential, and does not have volatile organic constituents. More information on the NOC fluid is available from the P2 Handbook, Data Sheet 3-V/B-4.

The ultrasonic cleaning process enhances immersion cleaning by improving the cleaning efficiency of the liquid cleaner. The OCUCS is scalable for cleaning large components (aviation support equipment) or small components (life support units) and can be bench mounted or used as a console unit. It can also be used as a mobile unit. The OCUCS system consists of transducers, a generator, two tanks, and a liquid medium. The transducers convert the energy supplied by the generator into sonic energy vibrations. These vibrations are transmitted through the cleaning tank and produce cavitation bubbles in the liquid medium in the tank. The formation and collapse of these bubbles create a scrubbing action that is very effective for removing contaminants. One tank is used for cleaning with NOC and the other is used for rinsing with demineralized water.

This system has been developed for the cleaning and rinsing of naval aircraft support equipment (SE) oxygen components, naval aircraft oxygen cleaned components, and naval aviator oxygen cleaned breathing components. This system is designed for the removal of thin soil films and particulate matter using only NOC and demineralized water. It is not designed for the removal of large quantities of soil or contamination. The unit has been used at both Navy/Marine shipboard and land-based intermediate maintenance activities (IMA) and training centers. Further detailed descriptions and technical specifications are available from the P2 Equipment Handbook, Competitive Initiative section.


Compliance Benefit: Use of the OCUCS decreases the amount of Ozone Depleting Substances (ODSs) used at a facility which will help the facility meet the requirements under Title 40 CFR 82, Subpart D and Executive Order 12843 requiring federal agencies to maximize the use of safe alternatives to Class I and Class II ODS, to the maximum extent practicable. In addition, a decrease in solvent use may decrease the need for a facility to obtain an air permit (Title 40 CFR 70 and 71). Replacement of CFC-113 with NOC eliminates a regulated chemical under SARA Title III, EPCRA reporting.

The compliance benefits listed here are only meant to be used as general guidelines and are not meant to be strictly interpreted. Actual compliance benefits will vary depending on the factors involved, e.g. the amount of workload involved.


Materials Compatibility:

The material used in the OCUCS (NOC) has been tested and is compatible with the majority of metals, plastics, and elastomers used in the construction of oxygen life-support systems. See MIL-STD-1330D, Appendix A, for a complete list of material compatibility. However, because NOC lifts paint, it should not be used on painted surfaces.


Safety and Health: NOC is safe for use in life-support systems including multiple atmosphere diving systems. Personnel involved with the OCUCS should receive formal training and be familiar with the applicable safety precautions and procedures for cleaning and testing oxygen systems or components. Ultrasonics typically operate in the 25 kHz to 40 kHz range; hearing protection may be required.

Consult your local industrial health specialist, your local health and safety personnel, and the appropriate MSDS prior to implementing this technology.


Benefits: The following benefits are possible with this system:
  • NOC is free of environmentally hazardous (ODS or GWP) characteristics, and is easily recycled using filtration.
  • Associated rinse water is easily recycled using demineralization.
  • NOC is a cost-effective replacement for CFC-113 in precision cleaning processes.
  • Ultrasonics can achieve very high levels of cleanliness.
  • Capable of removing small particles (smaller than 0.000005 meters).
  • Can remove debris from parts with complex geometries.
  • Decreases cleaning times over immersion cleaning.


Disadvantages: The potential disadvantages of this of this system are:
  • NOC has only a 12 to 18-month shelf life.
  • NOC requires thorough rinsing and drying of parts.
  • NOC should not be used on painted surfaces.


Economic Analysis: Two units were evaluated by the Navy in Competitive Initiative projects, a small unit (1.9 gallon tank capacity) and a large unit with dimensions of 38" long X 24" wide X 32" high. During these evaluations, an economic analysis was not conducted because the focus was an evaluation of system performance using NOC material to replace Freon. The capital costs for the units reviewed were $1,800 for the small unit and $5,800 for the large unit.

An economic analysis was conducted comparing the NOC system and a CFC-113 system. This economic analysis is outline in detail in the Navy Oxygen Cleaner (NOC) data sheet found at Section 3-V/B-4. In general, the economic information provided for a Payback Period of under one year.


NSN/MSDS:
Product NSN Unit Size Cost MSDS*
MIL-DTL-24800
OCC/NOC
6850-01-389-3859 5-gal $76.56 Click me
MIL-DTL-24800
OCC/NOC
6850-01-389-3859 55-gallon drum $499.03 Click me
Ultrasonic Cleaner System 4940-00-253-3905 Each $4,248.75  

*There are multiple MSDSs for most NSNs. The MSDS (if shown above) is only meant to serve as an example. To return from the MSDS, click the Back arrow on the Tool Bar.


Approving Authority: Appropriate authority for making process changes should always be sought prior to procuring or implementing any of the technologies identified herein.


Points of Contact: For more information

Vendors: This is not meant to be a complete list, as there may be other manufacturers of this type of equipment.

Blackstone~NEY Ultrasonics, Inc.
Formerly: CAE Blackstone (CAE Ultrasonics)

Model (small): HT-1206-NOC
Model (large) AQ-2-112-S

Blackstone~NEY Ultrasonics, Inc.
P.O. Box 220
9 N. Main Street
Jamestown, NY 14702-0220
Toll-Free Phone: (800) 766-6606
Phone: (716) 665-2340
FAX: (716) 665-2480

Email: info@blackstone-ney.com
URL: http://www.blackstone-ney.com/index.php


Related Links: Do You Clean Oxygen System Components? -- Navy Environmental Quality Initiative (EQI)
Ultrasonic Cleaning with Aqueous Based Detergents -- United States Army Environmental Center (USAEC)
Oxygen Component Ultrasonic Cleaning System (Large)
Oxygen Component Ultrasonic Cleaning System (Small)


Sources: Mr. Tom Rua, NAWC Lakehurst, April 2001
Ultrasonic Cleaning as a Solvent Alternative, P2 Handbook, Section 8-I-10,
Feb 00
Navy Oxygen Cleaner, P2 Handbook, Section 3-V/B-4, March 00.


Supplemental: Picture of Oxygen Component Ultrasonic Cleaning System (Small)
Picture of Oxygen Component Ultrasonic Cleaning System (Small)