RECYCLING WASH WATER USING CLOSED LOOP WASH RACKS

Revision Date: 9/01
Process Code: Navy/Marines: SR-02-99; Air Force: CL05; Army: VHM
Usage: Navy: High; Marines: Medium; Army: High; Air Force: Low
Compliance Impact: Low
Alternative for: Wastewater treatment
Applicable EPCRA Targeted Constituents: Benzene (CAS: 71-43-2), Cadmium (CAS: 7440-43-9), Chromium (CAS:7440-47-3), Toluene (CAS: 108-88-3), Mercury (CAS: 7439-97-6), Lead (CAS:7439-92-1), Zinc (CAS: 7440-66-6), Copper (CAS: 7440-50-8), Xylene (CAS:1330-20-7)

Overview:

A closed loop wash rack contains and treats wastewater generated from the washing of vehicles, construction equipment, and support equipment prior to reuse. The wastewater may contain fuel, oil, metals, and other contaminants. The specific equipment and process required to treat the wastewater will vary by site. Incorporating a recycling system to an existing wash rack will reduce water consumption and may eliminate the need for water discharge permits.

A typical process flow consists of the mechanical equipment (trucks, cars, etc.) stopping over a wash pad collection pit for washing. The collected wash water proceeds through a series of treatment processes discussed below.

In the first step of the process, free oil and dirt are separated from the wastewater. Sand and grit are removed as the wastewater passes through a "zig-zag" liquid-solid separator. Free oil is removed via a polypropylene coalescent pack with a high-density adsorption filter for removal of very fine oil droplets. Engineered flow baffling and an oil skimmer remove the floating oil and dirt.

The second process step removes fine particles and any remaining hydrocarbons. Water passes through a filtration system (i.e., quad cartridge filter, an adsorbent media filter for filtration down to 5 to 20 microns, a 30 lb. carbon filter) for removal of trace contaminants.

The treated effluent is stored in a holding tank where it can be discharged to the sewer or reused for washing. The holding tank is made of a ¼" thick, corrosion-proof polyethylene tank. Integrated into the treatment system is a centrifugal pump with a surge tank; a switch to draw reclaimed water from the holding tank into a pressure washer; a level control valve for maintaining a proper treated water level; an overflow drain; and an ozone generator.

Closed loop wash racks require dedicated maintenance. This may include replacing or cleaning filters. Additionally, all the closed loop wash rack systems are available as fully assembled modular units that are simple to install.

The following table provides an example of closed loop wash rack treatment efficiency as provided by vendors:

Table 1

Closed Loop Wash Rack Treatment Efficiency

Pollutants

Typical Pressure Cleaning Equipment

Closed Loop Wash Rack System
Oil & Grease:

57,500 ppm

5 ppm
Lead:

270 ppm

0.03 ppm
Cadmium:

2.2 ppm

5 ppb
Mercury:

0.067 ppm

0.2 ppb
Chromium:

1.54 ppm

0.95 ppm
Toluene:

55,200 ppb

5 ppb
Xylene:

694,000 ppb

400 ppb
Barium:

1,150 ppm

1 ppm
Silver: 14 ppb 0.05 ppb

ppm:  parts per million
ppb:  parts per billion

Close loop wash racks have been operating successfully at various locations in the United States, including the following locations:

  • NAS Willow Grove
  • Norfolk Naval Shipyard
  • NAS El Centro
  • NSWC Indian Head
  • MCAGCC Twentynine Palms
  • NAS Point Mugu


Compliance Benefit: Use of a closed loop wash rack will eliminate the chance of exceeding local discharge limits. Also, since wash and rinse water is recycled, less water will be used.  This helps the activity meet the requirements of Executive Order 13123 "Greening the Government Through Energy Efficient Management", which requires federal facilities to implement water conservation projects.

The compliance benefits listed here meant only to be used as general guidance and are not meant to be strictly interpreted. Actual compliance benefits will vary depending on the factors involved.


Materials Compatibility:
The materials used in the washing process may change depending on the system procured. Several systems require the use of low foaming and low emulsifying detergents. Facilities that experience winter weather may need to address the effects of salt on the performance of the detergent. (It is recommended to rinse with fresh water.)


Safety and Health: Care should be taken when handling chemicals and/or detergents. They are irritants to the skin, eyes, and mucous membranes. Inhalation of the fumes can be dangerous. Therefore, proper personal protection equipment is recommended.

Consult your local Industrial Hygienist specialist, local health and safety personnel, and the appropriate MSDS prior to implementing any closed loop system.

 

Benefits:
  • Reduces the quantity and cost of water used to wash vehicles, and equipment.
  • Reduces the quantity and cost of detergent used to wash vehicles, and equipment.
  • Reduces wastewater loading on wastewater treatment plants.

 

Disadvantages:
  • Heavy soil loading from tracked vehicles may be a consideration. This may require extra space for settling tanks.
  • For areas that experience winter weather conditions, road salt may be an issue. Salt concentration build-ups may affect the effectiveness of the detergent and cause corrosion. Extra treatment effects may need to be added (e.g., evaporators, distillers) to handle and treat the salt.


Economic Analysis: Closed loop wash racks are specifically sized to meet the needs of the facility. System design varies on the number and types of vehicles, equipment, and/or aircraft cleaned at the specific facility. Consequently, the purchase, installation, and operation cost of a closed loop system varies significantly.

A basic wash rack for automobiles and other small vehicles with an integrated wash water recovery system will cost between $25,000 and $30,000. If a facility has an existing wash rack without a closed loop recycling system, an above ground water recovery system can be installed. A 500-gallon above ground system costs approximately $10,000. If the facility has a clarifier in place, a wash water recovery system can be purchased for $5,000.

To prepare an economic analysis:
  • Gather facility specific information and data to identify the type of closed loop system that will meet your needs,
  • Determine the cost to install and operate the system, and
  • Determine the cost to maintain the system.

Other variables that can effect the costs associated with a closed loop wash rack include:

  • The cost of water,
  • The cost to treat and dispose, and
  • The cost of electricity.

The following economic analysis is based on information provided by vendors of closed loop wash rack systems and the following assumptions:

  • Existing facility has a wash rack and can accommodate an above ground water recovery system.
  • Labor rate and length of time to wash vehicles remains unchanged.
  • Minor maintenance to clean stainless steel double screen filter.
  • Cost of water (includes treatment/discharge) at $0.01 per gallon.
  • Cost to install one GFI dual outlet 15 amp outlet and plumb to existing equipment not included.
  • Cost of electricity for one pump is not significant.
  • 500 gallon above ground water recovery system with a single tank, ½ HP pump transfer station, 5 HP pumping motor, one particle accelerator, and a pump and motor enclosure. (This system is capable of recovering wash water from a maximum of 16 cars per hour using approximately 50 gallons of water per vehicle.)
  • Facility washes 250 vehicles per month and each wash uses 50 gallons of water per wash.
  • System provides 85% of the wash water required for each vehicle.
  • System provides 70% of the detergent required for each vehicle.
  • Cost of equipment based on GSA price.
  • Cost of detergent is $400 per year.
  • Closed loop system has a 15% drag out rate and requires 15% fresh rinse water to be added.

Table 2

Annual Operating Cost Comparison for Closed Loop Wash Rack System

 

Closed Loop System

No Closed Loop System

Capital and Installation Costs: $10,430 $0
Operational Costs:    
Annual Soap Cost $   120 $   400
Annual Water Cost $   230 $ 1,500
Annual Maintenance: $   200 $0
Total Operational Costs $   550 $ 1,900
Total Income: $0 $0
Annual Benefit: -$   550 -$ 1,900

Economic Analysis Summary

    Annual Savings for water recycling systems: $1,350
    Capital costs for equipment/process: $10,430
    Payback period for investment in equipment/process: 7.7 years

Click Here to view an Active Spreadsheet for this Economic Analysis and Enter Your Own Values. To return from the Active Spreadsheet, click the reverse arrow in the Tool Bar.


Approving Authority: Approval is controlled locally and should be implemented only after engineering approval has been granted. Major claimant approval is not required.

 

NSN/MSDS:
Product NSN Unit Size Cost MSDS*
None Identified     $  


*There are multiple MSDSs for most NSNs.
The MSDS (if shown above) is only meant to serve as an example.


Points of Contact: Navy:
Mr. Gary Anguiano
Naval Facilities Engineering Service Center
1100 23rd Ave
Code ESC421/GA
Port Hueneme, CA 93043-4370
Phone: (805) 982-1302
DSN: 551-1302
FAX: (805) 982-4832
Email:  anguianogd@nfesc.navy.mil


Vendors: This is not meant to be a complete list, as there are other manufacturers of this type of equipment.

N/S Corporation
235 West Florence Avenue
Inglewood, CA 90301
Phone: (800) 782-1582
FAX:  (310) 673-0276
Contact: Mr. Brent Feldman
Service: Drive-through vehicle wash equipment


RGF Environmental Systems, Inc.
3875 Fiscal Court
West Palm Beach, FL 33404
Phone: (800) 842-7771
or (561) 848-1826
FAX:  (888) 848-0047
or (561) 848-9454
URL:  http://www.rgf.com/


Blace Filtronics
2310 E. 2nd St.
Vancouver, WA 98661
Phone: (360) 750-7709
FAX:  (360) 750-7715
Email:  purecoat@teleport.com
Contact: Mr. Thomas Bewley


Sources: None listed.


[Back]