WASTE SEPARATION USING TROMMEL SCREENS


Revision Date: 5/00
Process Code: Navy/Marines: N/A; Air Force: N/A; Army: N/A
Usage: Navy: Medium; Marines: Medium;Army: Medium; Air Force: Low
Compliance Impact: Low
Alternative for: N/A
Applicable EPCRA Targeted Constituents: N/A


Overview: A trommel is a rotary cylindrical screen that is typically inclined at a downward angle which, combined with the tumbling action of the trommel, separates materials of different density. Trommel screens are used to separate commingled recyclables, municipal solid waste components, or to screen finished compost from windrow and aerated static pile systems.

Trommel screens are used by material recovery facilities to separate compostable paper from glass and other contaminants in previously shredded municipal solid waste. Smaller trommels have been used to separate labels and caps from crushed glass. Some trommels are designed to let paper pass through the screen while diverting heavier materials to re-crushing or a landfill. Other applications require multi-stage trommel screens which have meshes or plates of different aperture sizes. These screens may be used for the separation of commingled wastes with components of various sizes.

In composting applications, trommel screens are used to enhance the market value of finished compost by separating large particles and non-degraded bulking agents such as wood chips from the organic fines. The fines are used or sold as a soil amendment and the bulking agent can be re-used. Trommel screens are used when a high quality end product is desired.

The factors that influence the separation efficiency of trommel screens are:

  • Characteristics and quantity of the incoming materials
  • Size, proportions, and inclination of the cylinder screen
  • Rotational speed
  • Clogging of screen openings
  • Size and number of screen openings

The types of trommel screens available range from electrically or hydraulically stationary units with or without conveyors and hoppers to electrically or hydraulically self-contained, portable or mobile units with conveyors, cleaning brushes, and variable speed trommel drums.


Compliance Benefit: Waste separation using trommel screens can help facilities decrease the amount of solid waste going to landfills and therefore, helps facilities meet the requirements under Executive Order 13101 requiring executive agencies (e.g., DOD) to incorporate waste prevention and recycling in their daily operations. Use of trommel screens may increase the use of electricity at the facility. Under EO 12902 facilities are required to reduce energy consumption.

The compliance benefits listed here are only meant to be used as a general guideline and are not meant to be strictly interpreted. Actual compliance benefits will vary depending on the factors involved e.g., the amount of workload involved.


Materials Compatibility:
N/A


Safety and Health: Safety issues for using trommel screens deal with the operation of power equipment. Operators should be specifically trained to use the trommel screen. Machinery should not be used if workers are on medication. Proper personal protective equipment (PPE) including gloves, eye protection, and hearing protection should be used if needed.

Consult the base safety office on proper protective gear and training prior to using mechanized equipment.


Benefits:
  • Allows recovery of recyclable and compostable wastes from mixed waste stream.
  • Produces a high quality compost product for use in landscaping.
  • Produces a more marketable compost product that has higher value.
  • Allows reuse of compost bulking material.
  • Compost reduces the amount of waste to be disposed. Complete recovery of yard waste will reduce the amount of waste disposed in landfills by an average of 15.9% (EPA, 1994).


Disadvantages: N/A


Economic Analysis: Trommel screens which process material in the range of 50 to 100 cubic yards/hour range in cost from $50,000 to $180,000. The ecomomic analysis is for an aerated static pile compost operation. The capital costs include compost pads with air lines, blowers, a tub grinder, compost mixer, trommel screen, front end loaders, and offices.

Assumptions:

  • Process 25,000 tons/yr of wood and yard waste.
  • Produce 15,000 tons/yr of finished compost.Capital Costs: $3,000,000
  • Solid waste disposal costs: $13/ton
  • Operating costs (labor & maintenance): $25/ton
  • Avoided topsoil purchases: $50/ton
  • Hauling to landfill: $5/ton
  • Hauling to composting facility: $2/ton

Annual Operating Cost Comparison for Diversion and Disposal Using a Composting Facility

 
Diversion
Disposal
Operational Costs:    
Labor & maintenance: $625,000 $0
Landfill costs: $0 $325,000
Hauling costs: $50,000 $125,000
Total Operational Costs: $675,000 $450,000
Total Recovered Income: $750,000 $0
Net Annual Cost/Benefit: $75,000 -$450,000

Economic Analysis Summary

    Annual Savings for Composting Facility: $525,000
    Capital Cost for Diversion Equipment/Process: $3,000,000
    Payback Period for Investment in Equipment/Process: < 6 years

Click Here to view an Active S


Approving Authority: Approval is controlled locally and should be implemented only after engineering approval has been granted. Major claimant approval is not required.


NSN/MSDS:
Product NSN Unit Size Cost MSDS*
None Identified $  

*There are multiple MSDSs for most NSNs.
The MSDS (if shown above) is only meant to serve as an example.

Points of Contact: Navy:
Mr. Wallace Eakes
Naval Facilities Engineering Service Center
1100 23rd Ave.
ESC 426
Port Hueneme, CA 93043-4370
Phone: (805) 982-4882
DSN: 551-4882
FAX: (805) 982-4832

Mr. John Comstock
Naval Facilities Engineering Service Center
1100 23rd Avenue
Port Hueneme, CA 93043-4370
Phone: (805) 982-5315

Vendors: The McLanahan Corporation
P.O. Box 229
200 Wall Street
Hollidaysburg,  PA   16648
Phone: (814) 695-9807 
FAX: (814) 695-6684

  Re-Tech
341 King Street
Myerstown,  PA   17067
Phone: (717) 866-2357 

  Triple/S Dynamics, Inc.
1031 South Haskell Avenue
Dallas,  TX   75223
Phone: (214) 828-8600 
FAX: (214) 828-8688

  Wildcat Manufacturing Co., Inc.
Box 1100
Freeman,  SD   57029
Phone: (800) 627-3954 
FAX: (605) 925-7536

Sources: Mr. John Comstock, Naval Facilities Engineering Service Center, May 1999.
Handbook, Material Recovery Facilities for Municipal Solid Waste, USEPA, EPA/625/6-91/031.
Wildcat Mfg. Co. Inc., March 1995.



[Back]