WINDROW COMPOSTING

Revision Date: 05/00
Process Code: Navy/Marines: N/A; Air Force: N/A; Army: N/A
Usage: Navy: Medium; Marines: Medium;Army: Low; Air Force: Low
Compliance Impact: Low
Alternative for: Landfilling
Applicable EPCRA Targeted Constituents: N/A

Overview: Windrow composting is a process for biodegrading organic material aerobically. The process produces heat which destroys pathogens and produces a stabilized compost product for use as mulch, soil conditioner, and topsoil additive. The organic material is left to decompose outdoors, aided only by watering and mechanical turning for aeration. This method is simple, non-intensive, has a very low capital cost, and is commonly used by farmers, municipalities, and waste processing corporations. It is the slowest large-scale method used to produce compost. Windrow composting can be used to process yard waste, food, paper, and sewage sludge.

The process of composting begins with collecting, receiving, processing, and storing feed stock materials. These steps are then followed by mixing and pile construction. The compostable materials must be screened or hand picked for non-biodegradable materials, and then chipped, ground, or shredded into uniform particles that will decompose quickly. The high-carbon, dry wood and paper waste should be mixed in equal proportion with high-nitrogen, high moisture grass clippings and food waste to provide balanced nutrition for the organisms of decomposition. Feedstock materials are mixed using a pugmill, front-end loader, or paddle-blade mixer to distribute the carbon and nitrogen evenly. The material is then formed into piles to decompose.

Oxygen levels and temperatures must be maintained within a specific range to provide optimum conditions for the microorganisms. The temperature must be high enough to kill pathogens and weed seeds but not so high as to kill the microorganisms. The decomposition produces heat, and the organic material itself provides insulation. Oxygen is a primary requirement for aerobic decomposition. A well-aerated and properly mixed compost pile should not produce unpleasant odors.

Compost is formed into long piles called windrows that are typically 1.5 to three meters high, three to six meters wide, and up to 100 meters or more in length. Windrows can be placed directly on soil or paved area. The land requirement for a windrow composting facility depends on the volume of material processed. Generally, all of the materials handling and pile building can be accomplished with a front-end loader. The windrows can be aerated mechanically by turning with a front end loader for smaller operations or using a windrow turner.

Following the composting period, the windrows are broken down and reconstructed into curing piles for additional aging and drying of the material. Curing compost stabilizes it to prevent odors or other nuisances from developing while the material is stored. After curing, the compost can be screened to improve the quality of the final compost product, depending on the requirements of the compost buyer or consumer.


Compliance Benefit: Windrow composting will help facilities meet the requirements under Executive Order 13101 requiring executive agencies (e.g. DOD) to incorporate waste prevention and recycling in their daily operations.

States and/or localities may have additional regulations on composting which should be followed. The equipment used for composting may increase fuel use on site which may increase a facility’s need to comply with SARA (40 CFR 355 and EO 12856) reporting requirements and SPCC (40 CFR 112) issues. In addition, composting increases water use at a facility. Under EO 12902, federal facilities are required to implement water conservation projects.

The compliance benefits listed here are only meant to be used as a general guideline and are not meant to be strictly interpreted. Actual compliance benefits will vary depending on the factors involved, e.g. the amount of workload involved


Materials Compatibility:
A discussion of feedstock types should be conducted with the vendor to determine compatibility with the facility's goals for waste reduction.


Safety and Health: Safety issues for composting primarily concern the operation of power equipment and the potential health effects of working with decomposing organic matter. Operators should be specifically trained to use the equipment and should not operate machinery if they are taking medication. Proper personal protective equipment (PPE) including gloves, eye, hearing, and respiratory protection should be used if needed.

Consult the base safety office regarding proper protective gear and training prior to using mechanized equipment.


Benefits:
  • Compost reduces the amount of waste to be disposed. Complete recovery of yard waste will reduce the amount of waste generated by an average of 15.9% while the addition of food waste will divert another 6.7% (EPA, 1994).
  • Easy to implement and operate.
  • Handles a large volume of material.
  • Low capital costs.
  • Less equipment and maintenance needed than other composting methods.
  • Uses few resources.


Disadvantages:
  • Requires a lot of land for composting.
  • Attracts scavengers.
  • Often produces odors.
  • Requires large buffer zones due to odor and vectors.
  • May require a permit depending on size.
  • May require processing of rainwater runoff.
  • Compost can become anaerobic in rainy conditions.


Economic Analysis: The cost of constructing and operating a windrow composting facility will vary from one location to another. The operating costs depend on the volume of material processed. The use of additional feed materials, such as paper and mixed municipal solid waste, will require additional capital investment and materials processing labor. The capital costs include compost pads, grinder, compost mixer, trommel screen, front-end loader, windrow turner, and offices.

Assumptions:

  • Process 3000 tons/yr. of yard waste, food waste, etc.
  • Produce 1,500 tons/yr. of finished compost.Capital Costs: $600,000 (does not include land costs)
  • Solid waste disposal costs: $28/ton
  • Cost to pickup and haul waste to landfill: $50/ton
  • Operating costs (labor and maintenance): $165,000/yr.
  • Avoided topsoil purchases: $25/ton

Annual Operating Cost Comparison of Diversion and Disposal for Windrow Composting

 
Diversion
Disposal
Operational Costs:    
Labor and maintenance: $165,000 $0
Landfill costs: $0 $84,000
Transport/waste pickup costs $0 $150,000
Total Operational Costs: $165,000 $234,000
Total Recovered Income
(Topsoil Savings):
$37,500 $0
Net Annual Cost/Benefit: -$127,500 -$234,000

Economic Analysis Summary

    Annual Savings for Diversion Method over Disposal: $106,500
    Capital Cost for Diversion Equipment/Process: $600,000
    Payback Period for Investment in Equipment/Process: 5.6 years

Click Here to view an Active Spreadsheet for this Economic Analysis and Enter Your Own Values.


Approving Authority: Approval is controlled locally and should be implemented only after engineering approval has been granted. Major claimant approval is not required.


NSN/MSDS:
Product NSN Unit Size Cost MSDS*
None Identified $  

*There are multiple MSDSs for most NSNs.
The MSDS (if shown above) is only meant to serve as an example.

Points of Contact: Air Force:
Ms. Nancy Carper
Headquarters Air Force Center for Environmental Excellence
3207 North Rd.
Brooks Air Force Base, TX 78235
Phone: (210) 536-4964

Mr. Chuck Schwingler
Seymour Johnson AFB
1095 Mitchell Avenue
Seymour Johnson AFB, NC 27531-2355
Phone: (919) 722-5168
DSN: 722-5168
FAX: (919) 722-5179

Mr. Donald Hopson
U.S. Air Force Academy, 510 CES/CEV
8120 Edgerton Drive
Suite 40
Colorado Springs, CO 80840-2400
Phone: (719) 333-8393

 
Navy:
Mr. Wallace Eakes
Naval Facilities Engineering Service Center
1100 23rd Ave.
ESC 426
Port Hueneme, CA 93043-4370
Phone: (805) 982-4882
DSN: 551-4882
FAX: (805) 982-4832

Vendors: Valley Compost & Topsoil
P.O. Box 1013
Buellton,  CA   83427
Phone: (805) 965-6617 
FAX: (805) 735-1172
Contact: Mr. Don Landry

  Compost Systems Company/Fairfield Service Company
240 Boone Avenue
P.O. Box 354
Marion,  OH   43302
Phone: (740) 387-3335 

  Buhler, Inc.
P.O. Box 9497
Minneapolis,  MN   55440
Phone: (612) 540-9226 
FAX: (612) 540-9246
Contact: Mr. Wolfgang Ebert

Sources: Mr. Chuck Schwingler, Seymour Johnson Air Force Base, February 1999.
Mr .Tim Brecheen, Seymour Johnson Air Force Base, July 1996.
Mr. Wayne Fordham, Tyndall Air Force Base, July 1996.
Martin E. Simson, and C. M. Connelly, "Composting and Costs: The Bigger, The Better," Waste Age. September 1994.
Parsons Engineering Science, Inc. "Vandenberg AFB Recycling and Composting Feasibility/Economic Analysis for Municipal Solid Waste", November 1994.
EPA, Characterization of Municipal Solid Waste in the United States: 1994 Update.



[Back]