HALON REDISTRIBUTION/RECOVERY/RECYCLING/RECLAIMING

Revision Date: 9/00
Process Code: Navy/Marines: SR-06-99; Air Force: SV09; Army: N/A
Usage: Navy: Medium; Marines: Medium; Army: Medium; Air Force: High
Compliance Impact: Low
Alternative for: Virgin Halons
Applicable EPCRA Targeted Constituents: Bromochlorodifluoromethane (CAS: 353-59-3), Bromotrifluoromethane (CAS: 75-63-8)

Overview:

Halon redistribution, recovery, recycling and reclaiming are essential for preserving the availability of halons for mission critical applications. There are halon recycling services that are designed to bring halons back to Military Specifications. Halon recycling equipment is also available for those facilities that process large quantities of halon.

Halon 1211 and 1301 are widely used fire-suppression and explosion-protection agents. Both Halon 1211 and Halon 1301 have extremely high ozone-depletion potentials. As a result, production has been halted and use is being curtailed until existing supplies are exhausted. Any excess Halon recovered from existing non-mission-critical applications should be returned to the Defense ODS Reserve in accordance with Service procedures. Additional information on return procedures can be obtained from Defense Supply Center, Richmond at (804) 279-4525/5203. Mission critical applications for Halon 1301 includes:

  • Shipboard fire protection;
  • Aviation engine nacelle fire protection;
  • Aviation fuel tank applications;
  • Armored vehicle crew compartment explosion and fire protection;
  • Aviation dry bay fire protection; and
  • Aircraft hand held fire protection applications.

For Halon 1211 mission critical applications include:

  • Flight line fire protection;
  • Aviation crash, fire, and rescue vehicles; and
  • Landcraft air cushion fire protection.

Conservation of Halons is necessary to preserve existing supplies until replacement products and systems can be implemented. Actual use should be restricted to real incidents requiring fire suppression. Routine testing of systems for proper operation with the Halon product is discouraged. Surplus Halon is likely to be resold. Redistribution, recovery, recycling, and reclamation are all methods of meeting future Halon demand. Recycling is the process of removing contaminants (oils, nitrogen, particulates, moisture) by refrigeration and filtration so that the Halon can again be used in a fire suppression system. Reclaiming involves reprocessing the Halon to new product specifications through filtration, distillation, refrigeration, and vaporization. The military specification for Halon 1211 has been revised to allow the use of recycled halon. Also, ASTM has developed ES 24-93, an emergency specification for Halon 1301 for both commercial and military use.

Halon Recycling and Redistribution: Both E/M Corporation, a subsidiary of Great Lakes Chemical Corporation, and Automatic Suppression Systems of South Holland, Illinois, provide a recycling service to restore contaminated Halon back to Mil-Spec quality. In addition, they serve as a market for Halon 1301 and Halon 1211 for resale to distributors. The steps required to recover Halon include the following:

1) Verify that cylinders contain Halon 1301, Halon 1211, or other Halons.

2) Transfer Halon to blow-down tank for storage.

3) Recycle Halon through a recycling system to remove contaminants or reclaim the Halon so that it meets all necessary specifications.

4) Verify that the reclaimed Halon meets the necessary specifications.

5) Return Halon to storage cylinders.

When shipping Halon 1301, either interstate or intrastate, DOT requirements need to be followed. All shipping containers must be marked with the proper warning label (green label for compressed gas non-flammable) and proper safety plugs. Shipping caps must also be used.

Halon Recycling Equipment: Several manufacturers have developed recycling equipment for both Halon 1301 and Halon 1211 that recovers almost 100% of the halon and reclaims it to meet specifications.

In order to recycle Halon, certain components are required. The pumping system must be able to quickly and efficiently (99 percent efficiency to prevent the escape of Halon into the atmosphere) move the Halon liquid and vapor from the storage tank to processing equipment. Operating pressures range from 360 to 600 psig for pressurized cylinders down to a vacuum of 10 to 20 inches of mercury for cylinders which will be opened to the atmosphere. The recycling system should include modules for 1) removing contaminants by filtration and 2) removing nitrogen by condensing the Halon and venting the nitrogen. Filters should be replaceable without the release of Halon. In general, the two modules can run automatically and are not labor intensive.

For a more detailed analysis of Halon 1301 recycling equipment see the Pollution Prevention Opportunity Data Sheet "Halon 1301 Recycler."

For more detailed information on Halon 1211 and 1301 alternatives, see the Pollution Prevention Opportunity Data Sheets, "Halon 1211: Uses, Restrictions and Replacements," and, "Halon 1301: Uses, Restrictions and Replacements."

Halon 1301 and Halon 1211 are still approved for use, but only in mission-critical applications such as flight-line fire fighting and ship- and shore-based crash and rescue operations. Halon for use in mission critical applications is supplied by DLA from the Defense ODS Reserve. The purchase of new/reclaimed product is becoming more difficult and more costly. Procurement of Halon for any other uses requires a certification by an authorized technical representative (ATR) and approval by a senior acquisition official (SAO) at the flag/general officer or civilian SES level in accordance with Section 326 of the FY-93 Defense Authorization Act.


Compliance Benefit:

Substitutes for Halon 1301 and 1211 systems should be considered when feasible. Under 40 CFR 82, Subpart D and Executive Order 12843 federal agencies are required to maximize the use of safe alternatives to Class I and Class II ozone depleting substances, to the maximum extent practicable.

The compliance benefits listed here are only meant to be used as a general guideline and are not meant to be strictly interpreted. Actual compliance benefits will vary depending on the factors involved, e.g. the amount of workload involved.


Materials
Compatibility:


Halons are very inert and not deleterious to most elastomers, metals, or electronic systems. Halons do decompose to a small degree during a fire extinguishing event, releasing some hydrofluoric acid gases. However, the concentrations are so small (several hundred to several thousand ppm) and the gases so readily dispersed that material compatibility is not normally a concern, even if materials left in the enclosed space are sensitive to the acid gases/decomposition products of Halons. The smoke, ash, and soot of the fire more often cause damage.


Safety and Health:

Both dry chemical and perfluorocarbons have low order toxicities. However, care should be taken when handling any of these chemicals. Proper personal protective equipment is always recommended.

Consult your local Industrial Health specialist, your local health and safety personnel, and the appropriate MSDS prior to implementing any of these technologies.


Benefits:
  • Production of both Halon 1301 and Halon 1211 has been stopped, and any existing material will most likely be used for its originally intended purpose.
  • Recycling, reclamation, and redistribution are good methods of meeting future Halon demand.
  • Recycling provides a good alternative to disposal.
  • Careful use of the material for mission-critical applications will conserve current supplies and prolong the time over which the material enters the environment, thus lessening the immediate impact on the ozone layer.


Disadvantages:
  • Recycling and redistribution of halons are relatively short-term solutions and should be performed to meet mission critical requirements. Alternative substitutes for Halon 1301 and 1211 systems should be considered when feasible.


Economic Analysis:

Halon 1301 can be procured at no cost to mission-critical applications from DLA Defense Supply Center located at Richmond, Virginia. Any excess Halon recovered from existing non-mission-critical applications should be returned to the Defense ODS Reserve in accordance with Service procedures.

Vendors have provided the following information on Halon recycling services for bringing Halon back to Military specifications. For small amounts of Halon (e.g.,<100 lbs.), a recycling service will typically provide the recycling services in exchange for the Halon. For larger quantities of Halon (e.g., >1,000 lbs.) recyclers will purchase the halon from the facility or bank the halon for the facility for future use. The cost of these options depends on the needs of the facility. Vendors can store the Halon in the existing cylinders or bank it in bulk storage facilities. The following are typical costs for services:

  • Recycling and banking in your cylinders: $75/cyclinder per year
  • Recycling to Military Specifications: $2/lb
  • Recycling and storage in a bulk storage facility: $2/lb recycling fee plus $100-$200 per year banking fee and approximately $100/cyclinder for cylinder destruction

Assumptions:

  • 1000 lbs. of Halon 1301/year recycled and from five halon 204 spheres.
  • Labor Rate: $30/hr.
  • Labor to remove and ship cylinders: 5 hours
  • Labor to perform on-site recycling: 24 hours per cylinder
  • Shipping costs $300 per cylinder.

Annual Operating Cost Comparison for Halon Recycling Service and Halon Recycling Equipment

  Halon Recycling Service Halon Recycling Equipment

Equipment Costs

$0

$39,500

Operational Costs:

   

Labor:

$150

$3,600

Shipping:

$1500

$0

Maintenance:

$0

$400

Recycling Service:

$2000

$0

Total Operational Costs:

$3,650

$4,000

Total Recovered Income:

$0

$0

Net Annual Cost/Benefit:

-$3,650

-$4,000

Economic Analysis Summary

    Annual Savings for Halon 1301 Recycling off-site: $350
    Capital Cost for Diversion Equipment/Process: $39,500

Note: Recycling Services will be more cost effective unless very large quantities of Halon are recycled on-site.

Click Here to View an Active Spreadsheet for this Economic Analysis and Enter Your Own Values.


Approving Authority:

Approval is controlled locally and should be implemented only after engineering approval has been granted. Major claimant approval is not required.


NSN/MSDS:
Product NSN Unit Size Cost MSDS*
Halon 1301 Reclaimer 4940-01-395-9470 ea. $6000.00  
Halon 1301 Recharging Unit 3655-01-446-9335 ea. $7425.00  

*There are multiple MSDSs for most NSNs.
The MSDS (if shown above) is only meant to serve as an example.


Points of Contact:

Air Force:
Mr. Kenneth Dormer
SAF/AQRE
1060 Air Force Pentagon
Washington, DC 20330-1060
Phone: (703) 696-8549
FAX: (703) 696-9333

Civilian:
Fire Equipment Manufacturers Association
Phone: (216) 241-7333

Fire Suppression Systems Association
Phone: (410) 931-8100

National Association of Fire Equipment Distributors
Phone: (312) 923-8500

National Fire Protection Association (NFPA)
Phone: (800) 344-3555

Halon Recycling Corporation
Phone: (800) 258-1283 or (202) 223-6166

DoD:
DoD Ozone Depleting Substances Reserve
Phone: (804) 279-4525

EPA:
Stratospheric Ozone Protection Hotline
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Mail Code 6205J
401 M St., SW
Washington, DC 20460
Phone: (800)-296-1996 or (301)-614-3396

Navy:
Mr. Fred Walker
Fire Protection Engineer
HQ AFCESA/DFE
DSN: 523-6315

Mr. Doug Barylski
NAVSEASYSCOM 03G2
Phone: (703) 602-5084 ext 216
DSN: 332-5084

Mr. Jim Homan
NAVAIRSYSCOM
4.3.5
DSN: 664-3400

Mr. Joseph Gott
NAVFACENGCOM
Code 150
Phone: (202) 685-9177
DSN: 221-0521
FAX: (202) 685-1577
Email: gottje@hq.navfac.navy.mil


Vendors:

Automatic Suppression Systems
130 Armory Drive
South Holland,  IL   60473
Phone: (708) 333-4130 
FAX: (708) 333-9704
URL: http://www.automaticsuppression.com
Service: Halon Recycling Services

Walter Kidde Aerospace
4200 Airport Drive, NW
Wilson,  NC   27896-9643
Phone: (252) 237-7004 
FAX: (252) 237-9323
Service: Halon Recycling Equipment

Getz Manufacturing
1525 SW Adams St
Peoria,  IL   61602
Phone: (309) 674-1723 
Service: Halon Recycling Equipment


Sources:

Mr. Joseph Gott, NAVFACENGCOM, September, 1998.
Mr. Kenneth Dormer, SAF/AQRE, Washington, D.C. September, 1998.
Solomon, J., Halon Redistribution, 1994 International CFC and Halon Alternatives Conference, p. 426-427, October 1994.
Krabbe, G., Halon Recovery and Reclaim Technology from the Viewpoint of the Installers/Distributors, 1994 International CFC and Halon Alternatives Conference, p. 428-435, October 1994.
Huston, P., The Modular Concept of Halon 1301 Recovery/Recycling/Reclaiming, 1994 International CFC and Halon Alternatives Conference, p. 436-441, October 1994.


[Back]