7.0 Soil Material Durability and Finishes
- Soil materials in construction are often believed to be vulnerable to weather. This is true only of the outer, or finished surfaces. If proper roof and structural design is done, rainfall or severe weather will not affect the structural properties of the wall or the interior wall. Only the cosmetic surface of the earth material will be affected. Normally, the clay content of the material resists extensive wetting.
- Structures constructed of soil materials are durable, and are said to last more than fifty years. The US. government has documented over 350,000 currently existing houses and commercial structures of earthen construction in the US. Many of these have been in existence with minimal maintenance for the past 100 years. Some were built as long ago as the 1600's.
- Several options are available for finishing soil based construction materials. Two basic approaches exist: waterproof or breathable finishes. Waterproof finishes such as cement stucco are more permanent and more expensive initially. Such finishes will contain and trap moisture, which may be problematic; permeable finishes such as mud plaster are less expensive, less durable and will allow the wall to absorb and give off airborne moisture.
- Investigate qualities and claims of products before purchasing. If possible, test wall finishes before purchasing large quantities of materials.
- 7.1 Plaster
- Mud plaster is usually applied in two coats for both exterior and interior surfaces. The addition of straw is recommended in the mud plaster mix. This will help to reinforce the plaster, allowing for thicker coats and surface leveling. In addition, this will decrease the tendency for cracking of the plaster as it dries. High clay content soils in mud plaster may tend to result in a poor bond of the plaster to the wall.
- The finish coat is made of screened, fine materials. This layer is applied as thinly as possible while achieving full coverage. Plaster can be troweled or floated to achieve a variety of textures, and reapplied as many times as necessary to achieve the desired affect or to make repairs. When dry, the mud plaster surface will take a hard, firm set similar in hardness and texture to conventional plaster.
- The same stabilizers used in the preparation of the structural soil mix may be used to stabilize the plaster. Thorough mixing of the plaster mix is necessary to avoid an uneven finish.
- 7.2 Stucco
- Traditional cement stucco may be used on walls for a low-maintenance finish. While this may seem desirable, cement stucco also has disadvantages in that it has a different expansion coefficient than the wall material. This may eventually lead to separation from the wall, and may conceal structural erosion problems which may result from leaky pipes or roofs. Stucco netting is recommended to accommodate any settling and cracking of the stucco. Exterior stucco walls should not be painted with traditional exterior paints, which will increase moisture impermeability. A final colored coat of stucco or texture finishes may be used decoratively. For more information on both interior and exterior cement stucco preparation and application, see Adobe and Rammed Earth Buildings (Resources section).
- 7.3 Interior Walls
- Interior earth walls may be painted more successfully, and may also be treated with sealing compounds to reduce the tendency for dust to develop and rub off on furniture and clothing. Oil-based varnishes and resinous liquids can be diluted for such use. If paint is to be used, a sealing or sizing coat should be applied first. Whitewash can be prepared with equal parts of lime and white cement mixed with water. Natural earth pigments may be added to this.
- In addition to stucco or plaster, interior walls may also be treated with a variety of veneers including gypsum wall board or other interior veneers.
8.0 Soil Material and Energy
- 8.1 Thermal Characteristics
- Earth material walls are not especially good insulators. ASHRAE laboratory tests give a 10 inch thick adobe wall with 3/4 inch of stucco on the exterior and 1/2 inch of gypsum plaster on the interior an R-value of 3.8. A 14 inch wall with similar construction is assigned an R value of 4.9. In spite of these fairly low values in laboratory conditions, earth materials do have good thermal mass characteristics. Wall thickness of from 12 to 14 inches are generally considered optimum for thermal mass performance.
- Double wall construction can greatly enhance insulation value. Applied insulation can be in the form of rigid material or spray on insulation. Spray on insulation must be covered with stucco to protect it. Although the addition of insulation will increase construction costs, the resulting energy savings will offset initial costs. Some dynamic testing of high mass walls have indicated better thermal performances than the calculated thermal values would indicate.
- 8.2 Embodied Energy
The following figures, adapted from Adobe and Rammed Earth Buildings, reflect the embodied energy in BTU's required for the production and use of various materials. Soil block has a much lower embodied energy than many traditional materials.
Portland Cement | 94 lb sack | 381,624 BTU |
---|
Lime, hydrated | 100 lb sack | 440,619 BTU |
---|
Common brick | 1 block | 13,570 BTU |
---|
Concrete block | 1 block | 29,018 BTU |
---|
Earth (Adobe) block (mechanized production) | 1 block (10X4X14) | 2,500 BTU |
---|
Back to main Earth Materials page
return to
Table of Contents
This document was adapted to HTML by Bill
Christensen, sysop and environmental editor of Texas InfiNet, an online
community for progressive information.
Sustainable Building Sourcebook web version copyright Sustainable
Sources 1994-1999.