POWDER COATING PAINTING SYSTEM
CH3(CH2)2CHOH; plumbum, Pb; ethyl methyl ketone, 2-butanone, MEK, C6H4(CH3)2

Revision: 9/96

Process Code: Navy and Marine Corps: ID-05-03, ID-05-04; Air Force: PA01; Army: PNT

Usage List: Navy: Medium; Marine Corps: Medium; Army: Medium; Air Force: Low

Substitute For: Conventional Solvent-based, Waterborne, or High Solids Painting

Applicable EPCRA Targeted Constituents: Acetone (CAS: 67-64-1), n-Butanol (CAS: 71-36-3), Lead (CAS: 7439-92-1), Methyl Ethyl Ketone (CAS: 78-93-3), Toluene (CAS: 108-88-3), and Xylenes (CAS: 1330-20-7)


Overview:

Powder coating paint systems, also referred to as "dry painting", eliminates volatile organic compounds (VOCs), hazardous air pollutants (HAPs), and solvents, and produces superior surface finish.

There are four basic powder coating processes: electrostatic spraying, fluidized bed, electrostatic fluidized bed, and flame spray. Electrostatic spraying is the most commonly used powder application method. For all application methods, surface preparation (i.e. cleaning and conversion coating) is required to develop good coating adhesion substrate. Characteristics of the four different powder coating application techniques are described below.

In electrostatic spraying, an electrical charge is applied to the dry powder particles while the component to be painted is electrically grounded. The charged powder and grounded workpiece create an electrostatic field that pulls the paint particles to the workpiece. The coating deposited on the workpiece retains its charge, which holds the powder to the workpiece. The coated workpiece is placed in a curing oven, where the paint particles are melted onto the surface and the charge is dissipated.

In fluidized bed, powder particles are kept in suspension by an air stream. A preheated workpiece is placed in the fluidized bed where the powder particles coming in contact with the workpiece melt and adhere to its surface. Coating thickness is dependent on the temperature and heat capacity of the workpiece and its residence time in the bed. Post heating is generally not required when applying thermoplastic powder coatings. However, post heating is required to cure thermoset powder coatings completely.
CHARACTERISTICS OF POWDER COATING TECHNIQUES
Characteristic of Workpiece
Electrostatic

Spray

Fluidized Bed and Electrostatic
Fluidized Bed


Flame Spray
Size Larger Smaller Not limited
Material Metallic, must be conductive Any, except wood, not necessarily conductive Any, not necessarily conductive
Temperature Resistance Relatively high High Not relevant
Aesthetic Value High Low, not suitable for decorative purposes Low, not suitable for decorative purposes
Coating Thickness Thinner films Thick high-build films with excellent uniformity Thick high-build films; uniformity dependent on the operator
Type of
Coatings
Thermoplasts and thermosets Thermoplastic and thermosets Thermoplasts only
Color Change Difficult Relatively difficult Easy
Capital Investments Moderate to high Low Very low
Labor Low since highly automated Moderate depending on the automatization Relatively high
Energy Consumption Only post-heating Preheating and often postheating Low, no preheating and postheating
Coating Waste Very little Very little Dependent on the workpiece geometry

From Misev, Tosko A. 1991. Powder Coatings: Chemistry and Technology, Table 6.4, p. 350.

Electrostatic fluidized beds are similar in design to conventional fluidized beds, but the air stream is electrically charged as it enters the bed. The ionized air charges the powder particles as they move upward in the bed, forming a cloud of charged particles. The grounded workpiece is covered by the charged particles as it enters the chamber. No preheating of the workpiece is required. However, curing of the coating is necessary. This technology is most suitable for coating small objects with simple geometry.

The flame-spray technique was recently developed for application of thermoplastic powder coatings. The thermoplastic powder is fluidized by compressed air and fed into a flame gun where it is injected through a flame of propane, melting the powder. The molten coating particles are deposited on the workpiece, forming a film on solidification. Since no direct heating of the workpiece is required, this technique is suitable for applying coatings to most substrates. Metal, wood, rubber, and masonry can be coated successfully using this technique. This technology is also suitable for coating large or permanently-fixed objects.

The choice of powders is dependent on the end-use application and desired properties. Typically, powders are individually formulated to meet specific finishing needs. Nevertheless, powder coatings fall into two basic categories: thermoplastic and thermosetting. The choice is application dependent. Generally, thermoplastic powders are more suitable for thicker coatings, providing increased durability, while thermosetting powders are often used when comparatively thin coatings are desired, such as decorative coatings. The principal resins used in thermoplastic powders are vinyl, nylon, and fluoropolymer. Thermosetting powders use primarily epoxy, polyester, and acrylic resins.

Powder coating virtually eliminates waste streams associated with conventional painting techniques. These waste streams include air emissions, waste streams generated from air emission control equipment, and spent cleaning solvents. Powder coating also greatly reduces employee exposure, and liabilities associated with liquid coating (wet solvent) use. Because the powder is dry when sprayed, any overspray can be readily retrieved and recycled regardless of the complexity of the system This results in shorter cleanup times. In all cases, the dry powder is separated from the air stream by various vacuum and filtering methods and returned to a feed hopper for reuse. Powder efficiency (powder particles reaching the intended surface) approaches 100 percent. Other advantages over conventional spray painting include greater durability; improved corrosion resistance; and elimination of drips, runs, and bubbles.

Materials Compatibility:

Only workpieces that can be oven heated are suitable for coating by electrostatic, fluidized bed, and electrostatic fluidized bed application methods. Hence, these technologies are most appropriate for relatively small, metal objects. The flame-spray method allows powder coatings to be applied to other substrates such as wood, rubber, and plastic, and to large or stationary structures.

Safety and Health:

Powder and air mixtures can be a fire hazard when an ignition source is introduced. The concentration of powder in air must be controlled to maintain a safe working environment. Despite the absence of flammable solvents, any finely divided organic material, such as dust or powder, can form an explosive mixture in air. This is normally controlled by maintaining proper air velocity across face openings in the spray booth. In the dust collector, where it is difficult to maintain the powder concentration below the lower explosive limit, either a suppression system or a pressure relief device must be considered.

Inhalation of the powders should be avoided, as this can cause irritation to the lungs and mucous membranes. Proper personal protection equipment (PPE) should be used.

Consult your local Industrial Health specialist, your local health and safety personnel, and the appropriate MSDS prior to implementing any of this technology.

Benefits:

  • Eliminates air emissions, waste streams generated from air emission control equipment and spent cleaning solvents
  • Overspray is easily recycled for reuse
  • Transfer efficiencies approach 100%
  • Superior finish, greater durability, improved corrosion resistance, and elimination of drips, runs and bubbles

Disadvantages:

  • Potential variation in film thickness
  • Powder/air mixtures must be monitored to eliminate fire hazards.
  • System configurations are application specific

Economic Analysis:

The following economic data and basis was provided by the Powder Coating Institute. It compares a convention solvent based coating system to a powder coating system. The conventional system includes 2 water wash spray booths.

Assumptions:

  • 12,000,000 ft2 painted annually
  • Cost of convention coating: $11/gal
  • Cost of powder coating: $2.35/lb
  • Surface area covered by conventional coating: 250 ft2/gal
  • Surface area covered by powder coating: 96 ft2/lb
  • Labor required for conventional coating: 23,000 hrs/year (522 ft2). This labor includes preparation time and clean up costs.
  • Powder coating system will provide a 20% saving in labor, as a result of no paint mixing requirements and reduced clean up costs.
  • Labor rate: $45/hr
  • Waste generated: 167 x 55 gal drums of waste sludge generated by the conventional coating system. 13 x 55 gal drums of waste powder generated by the powder coating system.
  • Disposal cost: $300/drum

Annual Operating Cost Comparison for
Powder Coating System and Conventional Coating System

Powder Coating Conventional Coating
Operational Costs:
Labor: $828,000 $1,035,000
Material: $293,700 $528,000
Waste Disposal $3,900 50,100
Total Operational Costs: $1,125,600 $1,613,100
Total Recovered Income: $0 $0
Net Annual Cost/Benefit: -$1,125,600 -$1,613,100

Economic Analysis Summary

  • Annual Savings for Powder Coating System: $467,500
  • Capital Cost for Diversion Equipment/Process $145,000
  • Payback Period for Investment in Equipment/Process: <1 Year

Approval Authority:

Navy: Contact NAVAIR Code 530 (Ref. R 182002Z) for further approval for use on aircraft and aircraft components. Phone is (703) 692-6025; DSN 222-6025. This recommendation should be implemented only after engineering approval has been granted by cognizant authority.

Points of Contact:

Powder Coating Institute
1800 Diagonal Road, Suite 600
Alexandria, VA 22314
Phone: (703) 684-1770
Fax: (703) 684-1771

Scott Mauro
Naval Facilities Engineering Service Center, ESC423
1100 23rd Avenue
Port Hueneme, CA 93043-4370
Phone: (805) 982-4889, DSN: 551-4889
Fax: (805) 982-4832

Vendors:

The following is a list of powder coating system manufacturers. This is not meant to be a complete list, as there may be other manufacturers of this type of equipment.

Coating Manufacturers:

Cardinal Industrial Finishes
Powder Coating Division
901 Stimson Avenue
City of Industry, CA 91745
Phone: (818) 336-3345
Fax: (818) 336-0410

EVTECH
9103 Forsyth Park Drive
Charlotte, NC 28273
Phone: (704) 588-2112
Fax: (704) 588-2280

Farboil Company
8200 Fischer Road
Baltimore, MD 21222
Phone: (410) 477-8200
Fax: (410) 477-8995

Plastic FlamecoatŪ Systems, Inc.
3400 West Seventh Street
Big Spring, TX 79720
Phone: (800) 753-5263
Fax: (915) 267-1318

Pratt & Lambert Inc.
Powder Coatings Division
40 Sonwil Drive
Cheektowaga, NY 14225
Phone: (716) 683-6831, or Customer Service (800) 777-6831
Fax: (716) 683-6204

Equipment Manufacturers:

Nordson Corp.
555 Jackson Street
Amherst, OH 44001
Phone: (216) 988-9411
Fax: (216) 985-1417

Sames Electrostatic, Inc.
555 Lordship Blvd.
Stratford, CT 06497
(203) 375-1644

Gema
3939 W. 56th Street
Indianapolis, IN 46208
Phone: (317) 298-5001
Fax: (317) 298-5059

Source(s): Mr. Jeff Palmer, Powder Coating Institute, Alexandria, VA 22314
Miser, Tosko A., 1991. Powder Coatings: Chemistry and Technology, Chapter 6, Powder Coatings Application Techniques.
"Reducing Waste in Railcar Coating Operations,"Graco Equipment and Emissions Update, June 1994,pp. 8-9.