Pollution Prevention Case Study

ASHLEY FURNITURE INDUSTRIES, INC.

Distillation and Reuse of Waste Solvent

Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) Manufacturing wood household furniture, upholstery/2511, 2512.
Type of Waste Methyl Ethyl Ketone (MEK) and Acetone
Strategy Recycle and reuse spent solvents
Company Background Incorporated in 1945, Ashley Furniture Industries, Inc. began operations in Arcadia, Wisconsin in 1970. It has grown to become the largest privately held company in the industry and the tenth largest furniture manufacturer in the US. The company operates over two million square feet of manufacturing and warehouse space and employs over 2000 people in western Wisconsin. Ashley Furniture manufactures home furniture and has recently expanded into upholstery. Its markets include the entire US and 60 countries.
Original Process Solvents were used to clean and flush spray application equipment between color changes and for thin coatings. Only new solvent was used. The collected spent solvent was managed as hazardous waste.
Motivation Two high-concentration solvent waste streams presented an opportunity to reduce hazardous waste volume, disposal costs and solvent purchase costs. Approximately 200 drums of potentially recyclable waste were being generated per year. The project goals were environmental improvements and reduced costs.
Pollution Prevention Process A feasibility study was conducted to evaluate the use of recycled solvent, permit requirements and payback period. Several distillation equipment dealers were contacted for information regarding potential models. Cost, capacity and ease of operation were investigated for comparison. The results confirmed that this was a very viable project. The still that was selected has a batch capacity of 55 gallons with a cycle time of six to ten hours. It was sized for substantial operational growth.
Level of Commercialization All equipment is commercially available
Stage of Development The process is installed and in operation.
Material/Energy Balance Original Process
Feedstock
3,800 gallons/month new solvent

Waste
1,500 gallons/month hazardous waste

Disposal
Sent offsite for energy recovery

Energy Use
None

Pollution Prevention Process
Feedstock
(26% reduction) 2,800 gallons/month new solvent

Waste
(80% reduction) 550 gallons/month hazardous waste

Disposal
Sent offsite for energy recovery or incineration

Energy Use
Electricity for heating coils and cooling water for condenser ($98/month increase)

Waste Reduction
(63% reduction) 950 gallons/month

Economics Capital Costs
Purchase and installation of batch solvent distiller, cooler for condenser water, pump and plumbing and electrical hookups.

Equipment

Cost

Solvent Reclaimer

$17,885

Water Cooler

$1,157

Water Pump

$62

Transportation

$943

Plumbing Materials

$591

Electrical Materials

$644

Installation Labor

$1,800

Total

$23,082

Operation/Maintenance Costs

 

Cost/Month

Utilities

$98

Labor

$495

Supplies

$16

Total Cost

$609

Payback Period

Type of Cost

Net $ Saved/Mo.,
New System Vs. Old

Solvent Purchases

$3,035

Waste Disposal Fees

1,201

Operational Costs

-609

Total savings/mo.

$3,627

The overall cost of project is $23,082, and the savings are $3,627 per month; therefore, the payback period of the project is 6.4 months.

Benefits The predicted benefits of reduced waste, less solvent use, and a quick payback, have been realized. New solvent use has decreased by over 900 gallons per month. Fifteen fewer drums of hazardous waste are being generated per month. The process has also encouraged more effective methods for collecting spent solvent.
Obstacles An early concern was that spent solvents could absorb water and other contaminants which could compromise quality when used to thin coatings or flush equipment. Upon testing the recycled solvent, coating suppliers gave approval for use in flushing. Projections indicated that all recycled material would be consumed by cleaning and flushing operations.
Technology Transfer This process has been easy to install and operate. A water cooler was added to allow cooling water to be recirculated and reused. It is capable of recycling a wide variety of industrial solvents with minimal operator attention. Ashley is willing to share information regarding this process with others.
Company Address Ashley Furniture Industries, Inc.
Hwy 121 West
Whitehall, Wisconsin 54773
Contact Person David Ehlert, Environmental Manager
Phone: 608/323-3377
Fax: 608/323-7123
Pollution Prevention Resources Free, On-site Technical Assistance
University of Wisconsin Extension
Solid and Hazardous Waste Education Center
Milwaukee area: 414/475-2845
Remainder of state: 608/262-0385

Pollution Prevention Information Clearinghouse
Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources
Hazardous Waste Minimization Program
608/264-8852, 608/267-9523 or 608/267-3763

DNR Logo


Bureau of Cooperative Environmental Assistance
Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources
P.O. Box 7921
Madison, WI   53707
608/267-9700

PUBL TS-059